Binati Sheth’s Post

View profile for Binati Sheth, graphic

Let me help you write that book you desire | A Ghostwriter for Nonfiction Projects

Polyglot says: Bilinguals have bigger brains than monolinguals. ::sigh:: Let me just introduce the Motte and Bailey fallacy* today. A lot of influencers and intellectuals use this technique to deflect criticism (and blame). The Bailey contains: 1. Bilinguals have more developed brains than monolingual people.  (cites research to make the statement sound accurate) 2. Monolingual people who speak difficult languages (Mandarin, Japanese, Arabic, etc) are the exception.  (dodges incoming criticism) 3. English borrows from other languages, making it simplistic. (::sighs deeply and sharpens the pencil::) You step in and criticise this big-brained-polyglot with three points: 1. Your brain’s plasticity increases in many ways. Being bilingual or multilingual is just one of the known ways. 2. All languages have varied levels of difficulty. A language being difficult is an opinion (and depends entirely on the person using the language). 3. English is not simplistic. No language is. Linguistics is a complicated field for a reason. The offended polyglot reintroduces their Motte (this is often the hook, the CTA): I was saying bilingualism is good. You double down and say no; you are being disrespectful to English speakers and people who speak just one language. They double down as well by specifically picking apart the criticism. The point is, avoid the Motte and Bailey fallacy. Ya? It is easy to deflect criticism. It is difficult to learn from it. Learn from well-meaning criticism which informs (instead of instructs). Learn from open-minded criticism that asks questions (instead of making statements). *Official definition: A form of argument and an informal fallacy where an arguer conflates two positions that share similarities: one modest and easy to defend (the “motte”) and one much more controversial and harder to defend (the “bailey”). In case you don’t know, a polyglot is someone who speaks multiple languages.

Binati Sheth

Let me help you write that book you desire | A Ghostwriter for Nonfiction Projects

2mo

In case you are wondering why I say monolingual people, this is something I have noticed in the language learning community. Monolinguals, the word, exists and yet, they somehow like to remind themselves that they are people too so they use Monolingual people. 💀🥲 #sassyEdit

Tim Sullivan

Cross-Cultural Curmudgeon, Bull in a Ramen Shop, Professional Grandpa

2mo

Not sure what "big brain" means, but anecdotally speaking, bilingualism absolutely has benefited me and my children in countless ways. It has fueled my creativity both artistically and in problem-solving by showing me a view of the world from a different angle. https://youtu.be/nzHY-muy2Mw?si=gFsjv1ck4pZCA85c

Seiichiro Manabe

Technical Advisor about IT at PICOSYSTEM Corp. Thinking about social problems. #SDGs #Security

2mo

Windsor castle or Wizard cattle? In any case, switching things up and misleading people is something that makes people angry.  Even if that was wizardry.

HERCULES VORIDIS

Deputy Director at Bank of Greece (expressing only personal views)

2mo

Yes. Poly means many like polycystic or polymorphic. ΠΟΛΥ and glot derives from glotta or glossa ΓΛΩΣΣΑ which means tongue 👅 as well as language at least in late Greek (in Classical Greek they used phonee instead ΦΩΝΗ as per phonetic phonograph etc.)

srikaanth sridhar

Writing and Editing Professional. published author of book Concise History of Danish East India Company.

2mo

Well explained Binati Sheth

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics